DR Corner: Private FDRs – The Client’s Perspective
[2026] 3 FRJ 262. It is a truth universally acknowledged that Private FDRs (pFDRs) have been a force for enormous good. We all know and laud the benefits, but in reality how much have pFDRs really improved the experience for clients and, in fact, have they in some ways made things worse?
It is a truth universally acknowledged that Private FDRs (pFDRs) have been a force for enormous good. We all know and laud the benefits, but in reality how much have pFDRs really improved the experience for clients and, in fact, have they in some ways made things worse?
I don’t need to review the obvious benefits to clients of pFDRs: you don’t get bumped owing to lack of judicial availability; your judge has read all of the papers; life-altering decisions are made in a comfortable room as opposed to perching in a corridor, not to mention the all-important provision of lunch. These benefits have gone a long way to improving the client’s experience of the day itself, but there is still room for some improvement.
Most of us professionals deal with tens of pFDRs in any given year. In contrast, for most of our clients, it is the only such occasion that they will ever experience. They understand its importance and what rides on it, as well as the significant financial cost. We all roll out the statistics of how likely they are to settle and the dire alternative if they do not: many more months of litigation, spiralling costs and the risk and discomfort of a judge making a final order. The pressure of this can feel unbearable to someone unaccustomed to the rigours of daily hearings.
Moreover, the pFDR experience does not begin and end on the day of the hearing – it starts several weeks before, with the compliance (or non-compliance) with directions. We are all very used to that mad scramble in the final weeks when we are waiting for various valuations and reports to come in before we update our ES2s and advise the client on the proposals that they should be making. Years of experience tells us that however late all the moving parts may come together, they generally do. Clients tend to be, understandably, ill-equipped to deal well with this.
Carefully timetabled directions usually culminate in the exchange of proposals a week or two before the hearing but, hand on heart, how often can we say that these timetables are rigidly adhered to? And the ‘professionally friendly’ private element, knowing you are not going to be facing the wrath of an actual judge, does seem to make it feel like there is even less pressure to comply strictly. To compound the issue, how robust are pFDR judges towards solicitors about non-compliance with directions when those instructions are coming from a marketplace that may choose not to instruct you again? It seems to me that the consequence is a looser adherence to and respect for the court timetable in the approach to a pFDR.
Late compliance with directions certainly puts additional pressure on practitioners, but do we ever think about what this is like for clients?
It seems to me that the reasons for the prescriptive timetabling of directions have been somewhat lost. The timetabling is not meant to be primarily for our benefit, but rather for the benefit of our clients, so that they have time to ruminate on the proposals in a calm and measured way. They may use the time to work with a financial planner or other advisers in order to model the scenarios to give them confidence entering into negotiations. None of this is possible if the parties’ positions are not known until 24 hours before the hearing.
The last-minute rush to approve proposals, ES1, ES2 and position statement does not help the client to be in the right frame of mind to make major decisions about their life. We often tell clients that this is their one opportunity to resolve what is likely to be the most important commercial decision of their lives. And yet we work within a system which could not be much less conducive to them being able to do this successfully and with confidence.
When reflecting on my years in private practice and more recently as a divorce consultant, I have come to appreciate that for those of us working in the legal profession, it is our job to process lots of information quickly and to make fast and informed decisions. We have years of practice making considered decisions, multiple times in every conversation, every letter, every email. However, I believe that we completely overestimate most individuals’ ability to do the same, especially when it comes to their own affairs, with the heightened emotions this invokes. This applies equally to our clients who have been out of the workplace for 20 years as it does to clients at the helm of successful organisations. It is always a very different ballgame when it is your life, your home and your children which are on the line.
Our expectations of clients at the time of the pFDR is to process the information and advice that we provide them within a very short space of time and provide clear instructions in response. We can find it difficult and frustrating when they do not manage this or if they are overcome with emotion and need what feels to us like too long a time to talk things through, to think or to take time out.
I have recently worked with a client who, as a consequence of his difficult marriage, simply cannot retain information. His solicitor referred him to me as they were having to go over, and over, and over, the same advice, time and again. We deliberately drafted the directions in this case to take the vulnerabilities of this particular client into account, giving him plenty of room and time. We should not be adopting a ‘28 days fits all’ approach to timetabling. That is one of the beauties of the pFDR and yet I fear it is not being used as such anywhere near as much as it could be, to the cost of clients.
Just think about a lay client reviewing an ES2. These are documents that we work with day in, day out, but to a newcomer they take time to get your head around. Digesting them needs a clear and calm head – not something which, for understandable reasons, clients usually are able to summon up in the run up to a pFDR. Likewise, a position statement, the very culmination of their case, which they may have an hour or less to approve, sometimes late at night after putting the children to bed.
All of this is compounded by the fact that a great many of our clients will be suffering from the effects of trauma, which can impact every aspect of their experience of the family justice system. It can affect their whole ability to function, and principally their decision-making ability and judgement – which need to be at their optimum to make a pFDR work for them.
If your client is suffering from trauma they are likely to have one of the four main types of responses: fight – feeling angry, tense or on edge; flight – trying to avoid conversations, shutting down or feeling overwhelmed; freeze – feeling stuck, disconnected or unable to focus; and the less well-known fawn – saying ‘yes’ to everything, even if it is not what they want, just to keep the peace. None of these responses are conducive to successful pFDRs. The objective is to keep clients within their ‘window of tolerance’, which is the best state in which to make decisions and provide you with instructions. How can we, as professionals, help our clients to stay within their window of tolerance and away from these trauma responses? There are various methods and techniques, adjusted to meet that client’s particular response, that can be deployed by us all in the run up to and on the day of the pFDR to try to avoid clients slipping into these responses. I fear that there is still too little knowledge and experience of these vital client-focused strategies.
I do not intend to repeat in detail our calls over the last 2 years for the profession, judiciary and Cafcass to be fully trained in trauma-informed practice, but there are some very simple, practical measures we can take to make pFDRs easier on clients.
An obvious and basic improvement would be to try to ensure that directions are adhered to on time as much as possible. I appreciate this is often outside everyone’s control, but in cases where we can really see that our clients are suffering from trauma, or take time to process things, perhaps we can let them see early drafts of ES2s or position statements, even if not yet finalised, so they can sit with them for a while.
The reality is that pFDRs, the culmination of several months and sometimes tens of thousands of pounds of legal fees, are fast paced and clients can struggle to keep up. The days themselves are long and tiring even for the professionals involved – it is difficult to imagine what it is like for clients themselves.
As your clients tire, one of the big judgement calls of the day is the point at which to call time on the negotiations, either owing to lack of progress or your client’s ability to give instructions. One possibility, where budgets allow, is to consider a hearing spanning 2 days: with submissions and the indication on the first afternoon and negotiations to follow the day after. It gives the client the benefit of time and the opportunity to sleep on things.
We will usually have prepared our clients very well in terms of the procedure on the day, but we can overlook the physical and psychological impact for a client of sitting in a small room with their former partner, while being expected to take a pragmatic ‘compromising’ approach, at a time when even seeing their face, let alone hearing the submissions of their barrister, might induce feelings which can feel impossible for the client to manage. The concern about seeing their husband or wife and how they will manage that is something that very many of my clients talk to me about, and a more psychologically informed preparation session prior to the hearing (much like a witness familiarisation session before final hearings) can really help.
I do wonder about the extent to which clients follow the negotiation tactics of the day. The strategy can change very quickly following the indication and clients do not always understand the rationale. This can lead to them feeling let down by their legal team and hard done by in relation to any settlement.
As we all know, even after a successful pFDR, there is a great likelihood that, despite euphoria on the day, buyer’s remorse can quickly creep in. It is something that is worth warning clients to expect. We know that, following a successful negotiation, many clients will feel like they didn’t ask for enough or have given away too much, but they are often not prepared for that feeling or the understanding that it is normal. Indeed, the period following the resolution of cases is, in my experience, often harder for our clients than the period during which they are litigating. Their expectation will be that once they have their sealed order, all will be hunky dory but it doesn’t usually work like that – their nervous systems will often get them through the litigation only to find that they are hit by a tsunami of exhaustion and doubt in the months after.
It is difficult to talk about the post-pFDR period without mentioning the drafting of the order. We find that clients are ill-prepared for the fact that the deal is often not truly signed and sealed on the day. As we all know, it can still take several months to agree the wording of the actual order, during which the progress made on the day can quite quickly unravel.
If you are fortunate, a promptly listed directions hearing after the pFDR can put these issues to bed, but for cases that are outside financial remedy proceedings, or where the listing gods have been less favourable to you, this can go on for several months without resolution. Should we consider agreeing when committing to a pFDR that we will reserve the issues arising from any drafting back on paper to the original pFDR judge for assistance? I think this would help to avoid some of the most frustrating and difficult moments for clients.
Private FDRs were essentially developed to relieve our over-burdened court system, which happened to come with benefits to our clients. They were never created to address the client’s experience of the FDR – and that gap is where our clients quietly struggle while we call it a success. Without minimising the significant improvement that pFDRs have brought for our clients, I believe that there is, perhaps excitingly, still room for improvement.