Antoniou v Morgan [2026] EWCA Civ 1363
21 October 2026. King LJ giving the lead judgment with Sir Stephen Cobb P and Asplin LJ agreeing. A review, revision, supersession or appeal of a maintenance calculation does not amount to a fresh calculation and therefore does not end a top-up order made under s 8(6) of the CSA 1991.
Judgment date: 21 October 2026
https://caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ewca/civ/2026/1363
King LJ giving the lead judgment with Sir Stephen Cobb P and Asplin LJ agreeing.
Summary
A review, revision, supersession or appeal of a maintenance calculation does not amount to a fresh calculation and therefore does not end a top-up order made under s 8(6) of the CSA 1991.
Background
The appeals concerned two children belonging to Westley Morgan (‘F’), a former professional footballer: A, aged 12, whose mother is Leyla Antoniou (‘Ms A’), and N, aged 8, whose mother is Karla Morrell (‘Ms M’).
Following the birth of A, the Child Maintenance Service (CMS) conducted a maintenance calculation requiring F to pay the maximum amount of maintenance as his gross weekly income exceeded £3,000.
On 28 May 2019, a consent order made by Recorder Hay required F to pay Ms M £36,000 per annum.
On 15 September 2020, a consent order made by DJ Ashworth included a top-up order requiring F to pay Ms A £44,000 per annum.
On 24 September 2021, F informed the CMS that he was unemployed. The CMS treated this as an application for supersession, deciding on 16 February 2022 to supersede the existing calculation to a nil rate with effect from 24 September 2021. Upon being informed of that decision, Ms A and Ms M requested a revision of it.
On 13 October 2023, the CMS revised the nil decision due to misrepresentation by F. Appeals to the First-tier Tribunal (FTT) followed.
In March 2025, the FTT allowed the appeals and remitted the matter to the CMS, which on 25 June 2025 assessed F as having always had a gross weekly income above the statutory maximum.
On 17 July 2025, DDJ Hecht refused F’s application to dismiss Ms A’s application to enforce arrears of approximately £137,000 under her top-up order. On 8 December 2025, HHJ Hudd reached the opposite conclusion, dismissing Ms M’s application to enforce similar arrears under the 2019 consent order.
Issues
Per King LJ at [72], ‘Section 10 of the CSA 1991 and regulation 3 of [the Child Support (Maintenance Arrangements and Jurisdiction) Regulations 1992 (‘the CS(MAJ)R 1992’)] provide that any subsequent maintenance calculation made whilst a maintenance order is in force, has the effect of bringing that order to an end’ (King LJ’s emphasis). Under reg 3(2) of the CS(MAJ)R 1992, the order ceases to have effect, so far as it relates to periodical payments, on the effective date of that maintenance calculation.
The question in both appeals was whether review, revision, supersession, or appeal amounts to a ‘maintenance calculation’ for these purposes ([74]).If so, a top-up order made under s 8(6) of the CSA 1991 would cease to have effect.
The law
An application for a maintenance calculation is made under s 4 of the CSA 1991. Per s 11(2), ‘the Secretary of State shall … determine the application by making a decision’, unless the Secretary of State ‘decides not to make a maintenance calculation’.
Regulation 3 of the Child Support Maintenance Calculation Regulations 2012 (the ‘2012 Regulations’) defines a ‘calculation decision’ as:
‘a decision of the Secretary of State under section 11 (the maintenance calculation), section 16 (revision) or section 17 (supersession) of the 1991 Act determining the amount of child support maintenance to be fixed in accordance with Part 1 of Schedule 1 to that Act.’
F relied on this definition as identifying separate calculation decisions ([46]).
Review
The 2012 Regulations provide for an annual review of the non-resident parent’s gross weekly income against updated HMRC figures, falling 12 months after the initial effective date and on each anniversary (regs 12 and 19).
Revision
Under s 16 of the CSA 1991, a decision may be revised, on application or on the Secretary of State’s own initiative, where it is said that the decision was wrong at the effective date on which the maintenance calculation was made. One form of revision is a variation, which can increase the income taken into account on prescribed grounds (regs 69, 69A and 71 of the 2012 Regulations). Regulations 73 and 74 of the 2012 Regulations describe the ‘effect’ of a variation on the maintenance calculation, rather than providing for a fresh calculation ([55]).
Supersession
Where there has been a change in circumstance since the effective date of the last decision, s 17 of the CSA 1991 permits the Secretary of State to supersede that decision. For example, an annual review may result in the calculation being superseded due to a change in income.
Appeals
Section 20 of the CSA 1991 provides that where a person has made an application for revision under s 16 they have a right of appeal to the FTT against ‘(a) a decision of the Secretary of State under section 11, 12 or 17 (whether as originally made or as revised under section 16)’ or ‘(b) a decision of the Secretary of State not to make a maintenance calculation under section 11 or not to supersede a decision under section 17’.
Per King LJ at [64], this shows that:
‘supersession is to be regarded as a decision separate from the making of a maintenance calculation and indicates that a decision not to supersede under section 17 does not result in the making of a new maintenance calculation.’
Cessation
Under para 16(1) of Part II of Schedule 1 of the CSA 1991 (referred to in s 11(8)), a maintenance calculation ceases to have effect only on the death of the non-resident parent or person with care, there no longer being a qualifying child, or the non-resident parent ceasing to be a parent of the qualifying child(ren). Significantly, it does not provide for cessation on supersession, revision or review ([66]).
Top-up orders
Under s 8(6), the court’s jurisdiction may be invoked for top-up orders subject to there being: a maintenance calculation in force with respect to the child; gross weekly income of the non-resident parent exceeding the figure in para 10(3) of Schedule 1 (currently £3,000); and the court’s satisfaction that the circumstances of the case make it appropriate for the non-resident parent to make (or secure the making of) periodical payments in addition to the child support maintenance payable under the maintenance calculation.
The decision
King LJ dismissed F’s appeal and allowed Ms M’s appeal ([107], with Sir Stephen Cobb P and Asplin LJ agreeing at [109]–[110]).
There is only one maintenance calculation under ss 4 and 11 of the CSA 1991 ([3], [99]). Once made, that calculation remains in force until ended by one of the cessation events prescribed in para 16 of Schedule 1 of the CSA 1991 ([3], [67]).
Subsequent reviews (reg 19 of the 2012 Regulations), revisions (s 16), variations (regs 69, 69A and 71 of the 2012 Regulations), supersessions (s 17) or appeals (s 20) do not amount to ‘subsequent’ or fresh calculations within the meaning of s 10(1) of the CSA 1991 or reg 3(2) of the CS(MAJ)R 1992. They merely alter the existing calculation and the amount payable under it ([55], [64], [99]). Top-up orders under s 8(6) survive those alterations.
This construction is supported by reg 3(3) of the CS(MAJ)R 1992, which saves school fees and disability orders (s 8(7) and (8) of the CSA 1991) from ceasing to have effect, because those can be made without a calculation in place ([82]). No equivalent saving is needed for a s 8(6) top-up order, which can only be made where a calculation is already in force (ibid.). Further, the starting point is that only a court can discharge a court order; it would be unconstitutional for that power to be conferred on an administrative process run by a computer programme ([85]).
Construing every such alteration as a fresh maintenance calculation would create practical outcomes that are ‘absurd and wholly contrary to the policy imperative which underpins the CSA 1991’ ([3]). Every top-up order would cease to have effect following each annual review or on any supersession, even where the non-resident parent’s income remained above £3,000 per week, exposing caring parents to ‘recurring litigation, expense and uncertainty’ ([3], [83]–[84], [95]). Rather, the court must have regard to the CSA 1991’s purpose and context ([105]).